Everton remain entangled in a high-stakes legal dispute with Burnley, as the Clarets seek £50m in damages over alleged unfair relegation in 2022. The case, linked to Everton’s Profit and Sustainability (PSR) breaches, could have major consequences for the club and the Premier League.
Everton vs Burnley: Legal Battle Explained
The dispute stems from Everton’s six-point deduction in 2023 for breaching PSR rules during Farhad Moshiri’s ownership. Burnley argue that if the penalty had been applied in the 2021/22 season, the Toffees would have been relegated instead of them.
Burnley, who finished 18th with 35 points that season, believe Everton’s punishment came too late. Everton ended the campaign 16th with 39 points, but a retrospective deduction would have dropped them below Burnley.
Burnley Demand £50m in Compensation
Burnley are seeking £50m in damages, claiming the delayed sanction unfairly impacted their relegation. Finance expert Stefan Borson, however, suggests Everton may only face a settlement of around £10m—far below Burnley’s demands.
Everton would likely accept such a figure, as relegation would have caused catastrophic financial consequences. A reduced settlement could be seen as a minor setback compared to the potential damage.
Timeline for Everton Legal Case
According to a report from the Daily Mail (22 September, page 59), the hearing in London is expected to conclude in the middle of next month. However, there is currently no fixed timescale for when a final verdict will be delivered.
This uncertainty leaves both clubs waiting on a ruling that could reshape how financial breaches are dealt with in the Premier League.
Everton’s Turbulent Past and New Ownership
Everton’s struggles have been well-documented, including their initial 10-point deduction in November 2023, later reduced to six. Those sanctions highlighted the instability of the Moshiri era, when financial mismanagement left the club vulnerable.
The Friedkin Group’s takeover in December 2024 has since brought stability, offering fans hope of a brighter future. Supporters now want the Burnley legal battle resolved quickly so Everton can move forward under new leadership.
Conclusion: Settlement May Be the Fastest Way Forward
With Burnley pressing for £50m and experts suggesting a £10m outcome, a settlement could be the most realistic solution for Everton. Resolving the dispute swiftly would allow the club to close the chapter on its turbulent past and focus on building success under its new ownership.
About The Author
